Where To Get The Best Pumpkin Pie In Austin

By Ginny Reese

November 21, 2022

Photo: Getty Images

Thanksgiving is right around the corner, which means that pumpkin pie season is in full swing! There are plenty of places across the city that offer delicious pumpkin pie, but only one can be the best.

Yelp has a list of the best places in Austin to get pumpkin pie. According to the list, the best pumpkin pie comes from Upper Crust Bakery on Burnet Road. The eatery has tons of great reviews. One user wrote:

"Delicious home made taste on everything I have had. The sandwiches (chicken salad on wheat) are what got me started here. However, last week I ordered an Apple and Pumpkin pie which were divine. Each was seriously seriously homemade (better than what I can bake for sure) and cost $17 a piece. Now considering Randalls was selling pumpkin pie for $14.99 and the quality is 1000x's better check this place out. Thanks Upper Crust for making my life easier!"

Here are the top 10 best places to get pumpkin pie in Austin:

  1. Upper Crust Bakery
  2. Tiny Pies (Burnet Rd)
  3. Quack's 43rd Street Bakery
  4. Pie Jacked
  5. Sugar Mama's Bakeshop
  6. La Patisserie
  7. Tiny Pies (S Lamar Blvd)
  8. Capital City Bakery
  9. Texas Pie Company
  10. Bouldin Creek Cafe

Check out the full list of the best places in the city to get pumpkin pie on Yelp's website.

Advertise With Us
Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.