Death Lies & Alibis

Host Christy takes listeners back to rural Logan County, Ohio, to examine the 1979 disappearance and murder of Arthur Smith. The episode reconstructs the night he walked out of Rink's department store, the ten-day search that followed, and the moment a local farmer discovered Smith's bound body in an open soybean field.

We follow the timeline in detail: Arthur’s routine closing that Friday night, a brief 9:30 p.m. phone call home,...

Host Christy examines the disappearance and death of Abby Lynn Butcher in rural Perry County, Ohio. This episode covers the 16-day search, the moment Abby was last seen on February 16, 2022, and the discovery of her body behind an oil well on Reading Township Road 143. Guests and sources include family members and close friends—her partner Jason Rehart and his mother Gloria, sisters January, Lita and Riley, cousin David DeMalt, ste...

In this episode of Death, Lies, and Alibis, host Christy picks up where Episode One left off and follows the unraveling of Sydney’s final weeks: the hotels, garages, houses, and the names that keep surfacing. We examine timelines, the trail of suspicious fires (Drago Drive, Sherwood Avenue, Holiday Inn, Cherry Valley Lodge), and the cluster of men repeatedly connected to her last days.

Topics covered include the autopsy and toxico...

This episode of Death, Lies, and Alibis explores the life and tragic death of Sydney Larcher Bryson, a woman whose struggles with addiction, complicated relationships, and alleged involvement with law enforcement and criminal networks left her vulnerable. Found discarded in garbage bags, Sydney’s story raises questions about confidential informant use, trafficking, and the failures of systems meant to protect her.

Host Christy trac...

In this episode we travel to New Straitsville, Ohio, to examine the suspicious death of Amy Jo Nelson — an apparent homicide that local authorities initially dismissed as an overdose while vital evidence was cleaned from the scene. We explore Amy’s life, her medical struggles, and the immediate failures that left her family searching for answers.

The episode also looks at the opioid context, allegations surrounding a man in Amy’s l...

In this episode of Death, Lies, and Alibis, host Christy explores the 2001 disappearance of Patty Atkins from the Honda plant in Marysville, Ohio. Patty, a single mother and supervisor, vanished after leaving work to meet a co-worker she was secretly seeing; she had reportedly given him large sums of money and believed they were starting a new life together. The episode reviews witness accounts, investigations into Brian Flowers (t...

This episode examines the July 2022 crash in which 17-year-old Mackenzie Shirela drove into a warehouse wall at nearly 100 mph, killing her boyfriend Dominique Russo and friend Davion Flanagan. Evidence showed the act was deliberate, and Mackenzie was later sentenced to life with parole possible after 15 years.

The episode focuses on Mackenzie’s last jail phone call before her verdict, highlighting her lack of remorse, blame-shifti...

Christy analyzes Mackenzie Shirella’s first jail call before sentencing, breaking the conversation down piece by piece to point out deflections, minimizing, and lack of remorse. The episode highlights troubling moments where Mackenzie and her mother frame media attention as fame and avoid responsibility.

The episode centers on the victims, Dominique and Davion, and examines how the caller’s words and family dynamics reveal a narrat...

In this episode of Death, Lies, and Alibis, join host Christy as she delves into the unsettling mystery surrounding the disappearance of Crystal Ann Corbin. Set against the backdrop of Morgan County, Ohio—a community that hides dark secrets beneath its quaint charm—this story unveils a chilling narrative of a woman who vanished without a trace.

Through an in-depth exploration of Crystal's life, relationships, and the fateful days l...

In this gripping episode of Death, Lies, and Alibis, host Christy delves into the haunting cold case of Margaret Cicely Durant, a young woman found tragically murdered in a frozen field near her home in Grandview Heights, Ohio, back in 1987. Margaret's case remains unsolved, shrouded in mystery and suspicion, leaving her family and community seeking answers for nearly four decades.

As we explore the details of Margaret's life and u...

In this gripping episode of "Death, Lies, and Alibis," host Christy takes us into the heart of Zanesville, Ohio, a quaint town overshadowed by the haunting mystery of a brutal unsolved murder. Brandon Smith, a beloved 25-year-old, was tragically killed in his own home in 2009, leaving his family and community grappling with unanswered questions.

Listeners are drawn into a chilling narrative as Christy recounts the events leading to...

In this gripping episode of Death, Lies, and Alibis, host Christy delves into the chilling and unresolved case of Cody Morris, a beloved community member whose life ended unexpectedly on a cold December night. Nestled in the quaint town of Cambridge, Ohio, the tranquility of the township is shattered by lingering questions and whispered theories surrounding Cody's tragic demise.

Christy takes listeners on a journey through the even...

Welcome to a milestone episode of "Death, Lies, and Alibis." Join host Christy as she reflects on two years of relentless pursuit of truth and justice, where every episode amplifies the voices of forgotten victims. This episode isn't only a celebration of past achievements but also a look forward to future endeavors aimed at uncovering hidden truths.

Christy opens up about the personal journey of starting the podcast, highlighting ...

"Answers Among the Ashes: The Collins Case" is finally here.

On March 8, 2007, the peaceful town of Roseville, Ohio, was rocked by tragedy. A fire destroyed the home of Ronnie and Connie Collins—but the flames couldn't erase the truth.

Join us on Death, Lies & Alibis as we unravel the haunting details, explore unsettling questions, and dig deep into a mystery that's waited nearly two decades for answers.

Someone knows exactly w...

Podcast Episode Description: The Disappearance of Jeffery Fultz

In late 2023, 74-year-old Jeffery Fultz vanished from his small-town home in Cambridge, Ohio, without a trace. Known for his quiet routines, love for westerns, and a passion for fixing anything broken, Jeffery wasn’t someone who would just walk away from his life. Yet, one day, he was gone—leaving behind everything he needed to survive.

For his family, the search f...

Join us this Saturday at midnight as we delve into the perplexing disappearance of Jeffrey Fultz, an ordinary man from Cambridge, Ohio, who vanished without a trace.

Imagine waking up to the realization that a loved one has disappeared, leaving no farewell or explanation, just mysteriously gone.

For over a year, his family has tirelessly searched for answers, knocking on doors, reaching out, and hoping for someone to shed light on ...

The episode delves into the intricate case surrounding Ross Zwelling and Jeremy McGilton, two men whose past is rife with violence and manipulation. Allegations suggest Ross manipulated Dan Holdcroft by providing incriminating evidence against Jeremy, revealing a dangerous plot potentially leading to the murder of Leiland Cannon.

With both men now imprisoned, facing severe accusations, law enforcement sees a chance to reopen the my...