Fatal Blend

It’s our 100th episode, and we’re getting reflective… in the darkest way possible. Jay and Tee revisit the last 50 episodes, ranking the favorites and calling out the worst of the bunch.

What cases stuck with us? Which ones bombed? Pour a drink, sit back, and let’s talk serial killers.

Love the episode? Make sure to subscribe, leave a review, and share it with fellow true crime enthusiasts!

Want to Support us?  

Follow Us On:

Buy M...

In this episode, we dive into the chilling case of Randy Kraft, one of the most disturbing serial killers in U.S. history. Known as the Scorecard Killer, Kraft’s crimes spanned the 1970s and 1980s, targeting young men across California and beyond. Randy Kraft was a well-educated computer programmer who led a double life—appearing successful and intelligent while secretly committing a series of brutal murders. His victims were often...

In this episode, we explore the life and crimes of Scott Erskine, a serial killer responsible for brutal murders in California in the 90s and Florida in the 80’s. We examine Erskine’s his early criminal behavior. The episode also covers how law enforcement captured Erskine, the evidence that linked him to the killings, and the court proceedings.

Love the episode? Make sure to subscribe, leave a review, and share it with fellow true...

In this episode, we explore the life and crimes of Peter Manuel, one of Scotland’s most notorious serial killers. Dubbed “The Beast of Birkenshaw,” Manuel terrorized central Scotland in the 1950s with a string of brutal murders. We’ll examine his troubled childhood, escalating violence, shocking crimes, and the investigation that finally brought him to justice.

Love the episode? Make sure to subscribe, leave a review, and share it ...

In this episode, we examine the disturbing case of Stephen Port, a British serial killer who used dating apps to lure young men to their deaths. Between 2014 and 2015, Port murdered four men in Barking, London, exploiting trust, drugs, and systemic failures that allowed him to kill again and again. We explore who his victims were, how police initially misjudged the deaths, and the devastating consequences of those mistakes.

Love th...

In this episode, we explore one of the most disturbing true crime cases in British history—the lives and crimes of Fred and Rosemary West. Behind the walls of their home at 25 Cromwell Street, unimaginable abuse, torture, and murder took place for decades. We examine how their crimes went undetected for so long, the victims whose voices were silenced, and the investigation that finally exposed the truth.

Love the episode? Make sure...

In this episode, we dive into the disturbing case of Juana Barraza, one of Mexico’s most notorious serial killers. Known as “La Mataviejitas”—The Little Old Lady Killer—Barraza preyed on elderly women across Mexico City for years, blending in as a nurse, social worker, or caregiver. Her crimes shocked the nation and exposed deep systemic failures in law enforcement, profiling, and the protection of vulnerable populations.

Love the ...

Carl Panzram is remembered as one of the most remorseless criminals in American history. A drifter, arsonist, burglar, and serial killer, Panzram claimed responsibility for dozens of murders and assaults across the United States—and possibly beyond. Unlike many criminals, he expressed no regret, instead documenting his hatred for humanity in brutal detail.

Love the episode? Make sure to subscribe, leave a review, and share it with ...

Richard Evonitz appeared to be an ordinary man living a quiet life in Virginia—but behind closed doors, he was responsible for some of the most disturbing crimes of the early 2000s. In this episode, we examine the abduction and murders of young girls, the warning signs that went unnoticed, and how Evonitz’s crimes ultimately ended in a dramatic confrontation with police. This case is a reminder of how predators can blend seamlessly...

In this episode, we explore the life and crimes of Paul John Knowles, a serial killer whose charm and intelligence earned him the nickname “The Casanova Killer.” Operating primarily in the mid-1970s, Knowles used manipulation, deception, and violence to commit a series of brutal murders across multiple states. We examine his background, his transient lifestyle and the dramatic events that led to his death.

Alexander, R. ...

In this episode, we dive into the unsettling life and crimes of Gilbert Paul Jordan, a Canadian serial killer whose weapon of choice was one of the most deceptively ordinary substances imaginable,  alcohol. Known in the media as “The Boozing Barber,” Jordan spent decades exploiting vulnerable women across Vancouver, coercing them into lethal levels of intoxication while he remained just beyond legal reach.

Love the episode? Make su...

In this episode, we explore the life, crimes, and eventual capture of Lonnie Franklin Jr., infamously known as The Grim Sleeper. For decades, Los Angeles authorities hunted a predator responsible for a series of murders that spanned more than 20 years. We break down the investigation, the survivor who changed everything, and how DNA technology finally unmasked one of California’s most elusive serial killers.

Love the episode? Make ...

In this episode, we dive into the crime spree carried out by the Briley Brothers—Linwood, James (J.B.), and Anthony—along with their teenage accomplice, Duncan Meekins. In 1979, the city of Richmond, Virginia, was terrorized by a series of brutal, senseless murders that left investigators puzzled and the community paralyzed with fear.  We explore their the spree that shocked the nation, and the dramatic prison escape that added a f...

In this episode, we explore the case of Harold Shipman, one of history’s most prolific serial killers. A trusted general practitioner in England, Shipman used his position and medical authority to murder an estimated 215+ patients over decades. We walk through his early life, medical career, how he concealed his crimes, the investigation that finally exposed him, and the lasting impact his case had on healthcare systems in the UK a...

In this episode, we explore the chilling case of Rory Conde, a Miami-based serial killer whose crimes in the mid-1990s terrorized the city. Known as The Tamiami Strangler, Conde targeted vulnerable individuals, leaving a trail of victims along the Tamiami Trail. We break down his background, the timeline of his murders and his eventual capture,

Love the episode? Make sure to subscribe, leave a review, and share it with fellow true ...

In this episode, we travel to 1980s Paris to uncover the horrifying crimes of Thierry Paulin, a charismatic nightclub performer who became one of France’s most notorious killers. Behind his glamorous persona lurked a cold-blooded predator who targeted the city’s most vulnerable residents — elderly women living alone. Join us as we explore The Monster of Montmartre.

Love the episode? Make sure to subscribe, leave a review, and share...

In this episode, we dive into the disturbing crimes of Joseph Edward Duncan III, a convicted serial killer, rapist, and child molester whose horrific acts spanned decades and left a trail of devastation across multiple states. We explore his early life and the shocking series of events that culminated in one of the most haunting cases in modern American criminal history. From his troubled childhood and escalating violence to the br...

In this episode, we explore one of Arizona’s most terrifying true crime stories — the serial shootings that gripped Phoenix in fear during the mid-2000s. Between 2005 and 2006, two men, Dale Hausner and Samuel Dieteman, embarked on a violent spree of random shootings targeting people and animals alike. What started as thrill-seeking turned into one of the most chilling examples of partnership in crime.

Love the episode? Make sure t...