Mike's Minute: My thoughts on the chaos in the House

If you watched Parliament, as I did yesterday afternoon, you could feel it building. 

Question Time focused largely on the Treaty Principles Bill. There was a growing angst, Gerry Brownlee the Speaker spent far too much time calling for order, it was low rent, which isn't unheard of, but full of needless aggro. 

Then came the so-called debate. 

There were 11 speeches, lead off by architect of the bill David Seymour who spoke, as he has through this whole shambolic process, very eloquently. 

He was followed by Willie Jackson, who also spoke very passionately, until he called Seymour a liar and got booted out of the House. 

Most of the rest of the speeches were boring and said what you thought they might say, depending on what side of the House the speaker came from. 

National were in the invidious position of defending their position while not defending the bill. They can blame Christopher Luxon for this because how he let it find its way to the place it has is beyond me. 

As a coalition deal you either let it ride or kill it before you sign a deal in the first place. But this half-way House is the worst of all possible worlds, and it looked like it, as he was on a plane to South America and the poor sods, he left behind had to do their best. 

The whole affair, sadly, was not what you might want, or expect, from our House of Representatives. 

Beyond anything else, we appear to have lost the ability to debate cordially, to agree to disagree, to listen to other views, to be mature, to be adult and to accept that we don’t all have to be on the same page. 

By the time the Māori Party burst into a haka and wrecked it all, Gerry rolled his eyes and suspended proceedings for the day. 

I caught up with the fall out on Sky TV. God knows what the Australians make of it. This sort of stuff also goes global, so more embarrassment there as well. 

We look ridiculous. We look like amateurs, we look like petty, little children b*tching at each other. 

We look like Kamala Harris supporters on TikTok. 

I think, and hope, we are better than this. That lot yesterday in the House of Representatives is not us. It's not representative. 

Because if they are, we are buggered. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:00):
Now if you watch the Parliament designed yesterday afternoon, you
could feel it building. Of course, question time focused largely
on the Treaty Bill that was growing angst Jerry Brownly,
the Speaker spent far too much time calling for order.
It was low rent, not unheard of, of course, but
full of needless agro. Then came the so called debate.
The Treaty Principle's Bill had arrived. Eleven speeches, led off
by the architect David Seymour, who spoke, as he has

(00:21):
through this whole shambolic process, very eloquently. It was followed
by Willie Jackson, who also spoke very passionately until he
called Seymour a liar and got booted out of the house.
Most of the rest of the speeches were boring and
said what you thought they might say, depending on what
side of the house the speaker came from. National were
in the invidious position of defending their position while not
defending the bill. They can claim Christopher Luxon or blame

(00:42):
Christopher Luxon for this, because how he let it find
its way to this place is beyond me. Either as
a coalition deal, let it ride or kill it before
you signed the deal in the first place. But this
halfway house is the worst of all possible worlds, and
it looked like it as he was on a plane
to South America, and the poor sods he left behind
had to do their best to defend it. The whole affair, sadly,

(01:06):
was not what you might want or expect from our
House of Representatives. Beyond anything else, we appear to have
lost the ability to debate cordially, to agree to disagree,
to listen to each other and have different views, to
be mature, to be adult, to accept that we don't
all have to be on the same page. And by
the time the Mari party burst into a harker and
wrecked it all, Jury rolled his eyes literally and suspended

(01:29):
proceedings for the day. I caught up with the fallout
on sky TV later. God knows what the Australians make
of it all. This sort of stuff goes global as well,
so more embarrassment there. We look ridiculous, We look like amateurs.
We look like petty little children bitching at each other.
We look like Karmela Harris supporters on TikTok. We are
I think, I hope better than this that lot yesterday

(01:50):
in the House of representatives is not us. It's not representative,
because if it is, we're all bugged. For more from
the Mic Asking Breakfast, Listen live to news talks. It'd
be from six am weekdays, or follow the podcast on
iHeartRadio