True Stories? The Podcast of Plausible Doubt

In the quiet town of Niobrara, Wyoming, a late-night television broadcast is suddenly hijacked by disturbing imagery and cryptic messages. Viewers report nausea, anxiety—and faces they can’t forget. As panic spreads and authorities search for answers, the truth behind the broadcast remains elusive. Was it a hoax, a warning, or something far more unsettling?

In the coastal town of Rockport, Massachusetts, the legend of the “Gray Watcher” haunts the cliffs during storms. When architect Mary Hughes moves into the old Straitsmouth Island Lighthouse to restore it, she dismisses the town’s warnings—until strange events begin to unfold.

On a quiet Kentucky morning in 1876, something bizarre fell from the sky. Dubbed "The Kentucky Meat Shower," this mysterious event sparked curiosity, skepticism, and countless theories, ranging from the scientific to the supernatural. But even today, the truth remains elusive. Was it nature's oddest fluke, a gruesome accident, or something more extraordinary? Tune in as we explore this peculiar story.

In 1911, Italy’s luxurious Zanetti Express entered a tunnel and vanished without a trace. Decades later, mysterious figures surfaced worldwide, claiming they’d just stepped off that very train. Is this a haunting true story, or simply history’s greatest ghost tale? Tune in and decide for yourself.