Which Murderer?
Which Murderer brings together two hosts who talk about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer they would pick to kill them if they HAD to choose. Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Melanie aka Mel (the Scot) from Scotland. Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/) Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer) Explicit content and subject matter.
Episodes
April 19, 2024 • 29 mins
In Which Murderer’s 42nd episode of Season 6, the girls cover Mistaken Identity Murders. Mel starts us off with the tragically sad story of Ronan Kanda, before Holly goes over the also very sad and long Crystal Theobald case.
Saraid suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
In this week’s episode the girls go over yet more travel plans, there is a discussion around ninja knives (ninjas not included), gang life leads to chilli fa...
Saraid suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
In this week’s episode the girls go over yet more travel plans, there is a discussion around ninja knives (ninjas not included), gang life leads to chilli fa...
Mark as Played
April 12, 2024 • 27 mins
In Which Murderer’s 41st episode of Season 6, the girls cover The Devil Made Me Do It Murders. Holly starts us off with the gruesome story of Michael Taylor, before Mel goes over the famous Arne Cheyenne Johnson case.
Dr. Demi suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
In this week’s episode Mel is back from her own personal Disneyland - aka Liverpool - after almost killing her husband with cringe, there are graveyard tales from ...
Dr. Demi suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
In this week’s episode Mel is back from her own personal Disneyland - aka Liverpool - after almost killing her husband with cringe, there are graveyard tales from ...
Mark as Played
April 5, 2024 • 34 mins
In Which Murderer’s 40th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Supermarket Murders. Mel starts us off with the story of Payton Gendron, before Holly goes over the Zane Michael Floyd case. .
Kirsty suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
In this week’s episode the chiropractor finally gets some love and more work than he anticipated from Mel, the girls have some concerns about America, we learn a new word (cheeple) and special ...
Kirsty suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
In this week’s episode the chiropractor finally gets some love and more work than he anticipated from Mel, the girls have some concerns about America, we learn a new word (cheeple) and special ...
Mark as Played
March 29, 2024 • 26 mins
In Which Murderer’s 39th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Hitmen - They Murder. Holly starts us off with the old timey french assassin Charlotte Corday, before Mel goes gangster with the crimes of Jimmy Moody.
Dave suggested this week's episode - we think because of TV but maybe just cause he’s a super smart guy. THANKS DAVE!
In this week’s episode there is a bit of confusion at the start (on how to start), there are some more TV...
Dave suggested this week's episode - we think because of TV but maybe just cause he’s a super smart guy. THANKS DAVE!
In this week’s episode there is a bit of confusion at the start (on how to start), there are some more TV...
Mark as Played
March 22, 2024 • 39 mins
In Which Murderer’s 38th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Manhunt Murders. Mel starts us off with the manhunt for Raoul Moat, before Holly fills you in on the crimes and chasing of Christopher Dorner.
Holly suggested this week's episode - but she can’t remember why. And we can’t remember why.
In this week’s episode there is head on car rage with technical difficulties, rogue sheep, royal rumours, very confused celebrity footbal...
Holly suggested this week's episode - but she can’t remember why. And we can’t remember why.
In this week’s episode there is head on car rage with technical difficulties, rogue sheep, royal rumours, very confused celebrity footbal...
Mark as Played
March 15, 2024 • 25 mins
In Which Murderer’s 37th episode of Season 6, the girls cover LGBTQ+ Murders. Holly starts us off with the case of Scott Johnson the genius mathematician, before Mel fills you in on the sad story of Daniel Zamudio.
Karen suggested this week's episode - thanks so much!
In this week’s episode spring has sprung and the Easter Bunny is on his way….to be promptly eaten by Mel. The country of Switzerland is no longer safe either as she ha...
Karen suggested this week's episode - thanks so much!
In this week’s episode spring has sprung and the Easter Bunny is on his way….to be promptly eaten by Mel. The country of Switzerland is no longer safe either as she ha...
Mark as Played
March 8, 2024 • 26 mins
In Which Murderer’s 36th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Paranormal Murders. Mel starts us off with a story about the Hammersmith Ghost, before Holly terrifies you with the Greenbrier Ghost story.
Emma Jo suggested this week's episode - thanks so much! It was a blast to research.
In this week’s episode you find out that Holly quote, ‘loves paranormal shit!’, Jesus is claimed, there are some excellent TV recommendations, you a...
Emma Jo suggested this week's episode - thanks so much! It was a blast to research.
In this week’s episode you find out that Holly quote, ‘loves paranormal shit!’, Jesus is claimed, there are some excellent TV recommendations, you a...
Mark as Played
March 1, 2024 • 31 mins
In Which Murderer’s 35th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Tire Track Murders. Holly starts us off with a case involving Sean Vincent Gillis, before Mel tells you all about the Russell Williams story.
Dr Demi suggested this week's episode - thanks so much!
This week the snow hating podcast covers upcoming trips, makeup and misunderstandings. The girls outdo themselves with memory struggles and Mel discusses her great football tra...
Dr Demi suggested this week's episode - thanks so much!
This week the snow hating podcast covers upcoming trips, makeup and misunderstandings. The girls outdo themselves with memory struggles and Mel discusses her great football tra...
Mark as Played
February 23, 2024 • 30 mins
This episode is sponsored by Magic Mind - the World’s First Productivity Shots!
Visit www.magicmind.com/murderer and enter code MURDERER20 for great discounts!
In Which Murderer’s 34th episode of Season 6, the girls cover cases where victims were Murdered with No Trace. Mel starts us off with a Tom Hardy case involving Jack 'the hat' McVitie, before Holly tells you all about the Michelle Mockbee story.
Canadian Natalie suggested this...
Visit www.magicmind.com/murderer and enter code MURDERER20 for great discounts!
In Which Murderer’s 34th episode of Season 6, the girls cover cases where victims were Murdered with No Trace. Mel starts us off with a Tom Hardy case involving Jack 'the hat' McVitie, before Holly tells you all about the Michelle Mockbee story.
Canadian Natalie suggested this...
Mark as Played
February 16, 2024 • 29 mins
This episode is sponsored by Magic Mind - the World’s First Productivity Shots!
Visit https://www.magicmind.com/murderer and use code MURDERER20 for great discounts!
In Which Murderer’s 33rd episode of Season 6, the girls cover the incredibly important topic of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW). Holly starts us off with a sad case involving Destiny Tom, before Mel tells you all about Cheryl Ann Joe whose death inspired a ...
Visit https://www.magicmind.com/murderer and use code MURDERER20 for great discounts!
In Which Murderer’s 33rd episode of Season 6, the girls cover the incredibly important topic of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW). Holly starts us off with a sad case involving Destiny Tom, before Mel tells you all about Cheryl Ann Joe whose death inspired a ...
Mark as Played
February 9, 2024 • 40 mins
This episode is sponsored by Magic Mind - the World’s First Productivity Shots!
In Which Murderer’s 32nd episode of Season 6, the girls cover Murderers Who Kill Again. Mel starts us off with a complicated ethical case involving John Staffen, before Holly tells you all about Kenneth McDuff and his terrible crimes.
Kirsty who is in fact NOT FROM SCOTLAND suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
In this episode we find out it is the...
In Which Murderer’s 32nd episode of Season 6, the girls cover Murderers Who Kill Again. Mel starts us off with a complicated ethical case involving John Staffen, before Holly tells you all about Kenneth McDuff and his terrible crimes.
Kirsty who is in fact NOT FROM SCOTLAND suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!
In this episode we find out it is the...
Mark as Played
February 2, 2024 • 28 mins
This episode is sponsored by Magic Mind - the World's First Productivity Shot!
In Which Murderer’s 31st episode of Season 6, the girls cover Furniture Murders. Holly starts us off with a case involving Troy Scott Johnston, before Mel tells you all about Tommy Zeigler.
Holly suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much for a terrible idea Holly! This is why the girls cannot be trusted with picking topics.
In this episode it’s very dar...
In Which Murderer’s 31st episode of Season 6, the girls cover Furniture Murders. Holly starts us off with a case involving Troy Scott Johnston, before Mel tells you all about Tommy Zeigler.
Holly suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much for a terrible idea Holly! This is why the girls cannot be trusted with picking topics.
In this episode it’s very dar...
Mark as Played
January 26, 2024 • 29 mins
This episode is sponsored by Magic Mind - the world's first productivity shot!
In Which Murderer’s 30th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Recorded Murders. Mel starts us off with a recent case involving Daniel White, before Holly tells you all about the shocking murderers Richard Davis & Dena Riley.
Mel’s Co-Workers suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much and huge high fives for putting up with Mel!
In this episode the gir...
In Which Murderer’s 30th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Recorded Murders. Mel starts us off with a recent case involving Daniel White, before Holly tells you all about the shocking murderers Richard Davis & Dena Riley.
Mel’s Co-Workers suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much and huge high fives for putting up with Mel!
In this episode the gir...
Mark as Played
January 19, 2024 • 29 mins
This episode is sponsored by Magic Mind - the world's first productivity shot!
In Which Murderer’s twenty ninth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Judge Murders. Holly starts us off with Canadian Judge Jacques Delisle, before Mel tells you all about the horrific murder of Cecilia Koranteng-Addow.
Karen suggested this topic - thanks so much!
In this episode the girls wish you a happy 2024 while Holly is still being tortured by 2023, ...
In Which Murderer’s twenty ninth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Judge Murders. Holly starts us off with Canadian Judge Jacques Delisle, before Mel tells you all about the horrific murder of Cecilia Koranteng-Addow.
Karen suggested this topic - thanks so much!
In this episode the girls wish you a happy 2024 while Holly is still being tortured by 2023, ...
Mark as Played
January 12, 2024 • 33 mins
In Which Murderer’s twenty eighth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Colour Murders. Mel starts us off with the legendary case of the Black Dahlia, before Holly tells you all about the Red Barn murder from oldy times.
Ricky suggested this topic……thanks Ricky!
In this episode Holly tries to murder Mel by ‘making’ her record too many things, a certain flower gets butchered, Holly has new career plans as a Mole Catcher and there are s...
Ricky suggested this topic……thanks Ricky!
In this episode Holly tries to murder Mel by ‘making’ her record too many things, a certain flower gets butchered, Holly has new career plans as a Mole Catcher and there are s...
Mark as Played
January 5, 2024 • 31 mins
In Which Murderer’s twenty seventh episode of Season 6, the girls cover Urban Legend Murders. Holly starts us off with the terrifying story of Janett Christman, before Mel tells you all about the murders committed by Andre Rand.
Kirsty suggested this topic. We think this half of the murder twin duo is Scottish but we also think aliens exist and created math to slow down the human race so……
In this episode it’s definitely Mel’s sleepy...
Kirsty suggested this topic. We think this half of the murder twin duo is Scottish but we also think aliens exist and created math to slow down the human race so……
In this episode it’s definitely Mel’s sleepy...
Mark as Played
December 29, 2023 • 34 mins
In Which Murderer’s twenty sixth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Murdered in the Sunshine. Mel starts us off with the story of Leigh Leigh, before Holly tells you (again) all about the murder of Daniel James Morcombe. Both are tragic traumatic deaths of young people so listener caution is advised.
Dave suggested this topic, but as he has abandoned Which Murder in favour of a lame award winning scientist he has received minus on...
Dave suggested this topic, but as he has abandoned Which Murder in favour of a lame award winning scientist he has received minus on...
Mark as Played
December 22, 2023 • 30 mins
In Which Murderer’s twenty fifth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Unlikely Murders. We have a conspiracy theory, mystery and murder when Holly starts us off with the story of Rodney David Marks, before Mel tells you all about the unlikely assassination involving Stig Engstrom.
Saraid suggested this episode topic - and she would like it known she WAS NOT BUYING DEEP FRIED PIZZA.
In this episode you get a cosy weather update on S...
Saraid suggested this episode topic - and she would like it known she WAS NOT BUYING DEEP FRIED PIZZA.
In this episode you get a cosy weather update on S...
Mark as Played
December 15, 2023 • 27 mins
In Which Murderer’s twenty fourth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Terrible Excuse Murders. One of them hits close to home for Mel who starts us off with the crazy story of John Wesley Hardin, before Holly tells you all about a family tragedy involving Fergus Glen.
Mel suggested this one. She gets no shoutout because she can’t remember why she suggested it.
In this episode the girls gift you a slow car crash, Holly has misplaced...
Mel suggested this one. She gets no shoutout because she can’t remember why she suggested it.
In this episode the girls gift you a slow car crash, Holly has misplaced...
Mark as Played
December 8, 2023 • 27 mins
In Which Murderer’s twenty third episode of Season 6, the girls cover Mob Massacre Murders. Holly starts us off with the brutal story of Farkhunda Malikzada, before Mel tells you all about the Rosewood Massacre.
Shoutout to Emma Jo for the suggestion!
In this episode the girls argue quite dramatically over bones and chiropractors, Holly reveals her cliffhanger which Mel is not impressed with, there is a rant about ‘ums’ and Holly’s m...
Shoutout to Emma Jo for the suggestion!
In this episode the girls argue quite dramatically over bones and chiropractors, Holly reveals her cliffhanger which Mel is not impressed with, there is a rant about ‘ums’ and Holly’s m...
Mark as Played
Popular Podcasts
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations.
Anna Sale explores the big questions and hard choices that are often left out of polite conversation.
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people.
A straightforward look at the day's top news in 20 minutes. Powered by ABC News. Hosted by Brad Mielke.