Book Review: The Lost Key by S. D. Smith

When Ember’s End was released, many Green Ember fans wondered if it marked the conclusion of the beloved series. Yet, S. D. Smith continues to surprise and delight us with new stories that delve deeper into the Green Ember world.

When I spoke with Smith this summer, he mentioned that this might be the first year without a new Green Ember story. Imagine my surprise and excitement when a novella appeared in my inbox, simply titled: “A surprise new Green Ember book in time for Christmas!”

The Lost Key is an exciting short story that transports readers back to the events at Halfwind Citadel. Nestled between The First Fowler and Ember Falls, The Lost Key is packed with suspense, action, and a high-stakes quest to uncover the mysterious “lost key.” This novella has everything fans have come to love: the return of old friends, lots of humor, an exciting adventure, answers to old questions, and a setting we love. The stakes are high: there’s a traitor in their midst, wolves closing in, cryptic clues to decipher, and a desperate race to protect their world.

Smith’s signature style blends heart-pounding action, unexpected twists, mystery, and the warm humor that is a hallmark of the Green Ember series. Jo Shanks’s gentle side gets some well-deserved attention, and Picket and Helmer’s antics make us laugh out loud, as usual. Parents might chuckle—or cringe—at the “zipline” escapade, while kids will undoubtedly be inspired by the courage and cleverness of their favorite characters.

And just when you think the story has reached its conclusion, Smith delivers a delightful surprise: a bonus short story tucked at the end. This unexpected treat hints at even more adventures to come, leaving readers with a renewed hope for future Green Ember tales.

The Lost Key is a perfect Christmas gift for fans of the series and its small size guarantees that it will fit into most stockings. Thank goodness we have some Green Ember goodness to put under the tree again this year!