September 13, 2024 • 25 mins
In this gripping episode of True Crime Case Files, we delve into the tragic murder of Willy Tanners, a beloved hardware store owner from Tifton, Georgia. Discover how an obsessive secret love affair with a teenage girl spiraled out of control, leading to a brutal Christmas-time murder that shocked the small town.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
Welcome to another episode of true crime Case Files. In
today's episode, we delve into a tragic tale of love, obsession,
and murder in the small town of Tifton, Georgia. The
story that follows is one of dark secrets, emotional turmoil,
and a brutal killing that left a lasting scar on
everyone involved. This is the case of a respected man
(00:20):
whose life ended in a nightmarish fashion by an unexpected killer,
leaving behind questions that would haunt the town forever. Willie
Tanners forty nine was a well known and respected figure
in the small southern town at Tifton, Georgia. He owned
Tanner's Hardware, a local store that had been serving the
community for over two decades. Known for its friendly service
(00:41):
and wide selection of tools and supplies, Tanner's Hardware was
the kind of place where neighbors could count on finding
what they needed, whether it was a simple screwdriver or
advice on how to fix a leaky faucet. Willie was
often seen behind the counter, greeting customers with a warm
smile and chatting about everything from the weather to last
night's episode of Jim. Willie's life appeared ideal to those
(01:02):
who knew him. He was married to Lynne Tanners, forty eight,
his high school sweetheart, and the couple was often involved
in local church activities and charity events. They lived in
a modest but well kept home, decorated for the holidays
with twinkling lights and a wraith on the front door.
Willie's pride and joy was his two thousand and seven
Ford F one hundred and fifty, which he named Billy
(01:25):
James Contester, which he kept in pristine condition. He was
also an avid fan of the University of Georgia Bulldogs,
and his saturdays in the fall were spent watching football games,
often with friends and family. However, beneath this seemingly perfect exterior,
Willie was hiding a dark secret. Despite his reputation as
a devoted husband and upstanding citizen, Willie had become involved
(01:48):
in a secret affair with Madison Kelly, an eighteen year
old high school senior. Madison, known for her striking looks
and intelligence, was a regular customer at the hardware store.
Over time, a friendship developed that quickly turned into a
sexual relationship. Torn between guilt and desire, Willie struggled with
his conscience. As the holiday season approached. He knew the
(02:10):
affair was wrong, but he was unable to break free
from the emotional entanglement that had developed. The relationship was
torrid and extremely intense, with Willie struggling between his guilt
and his growing attachment to Madison. In the days leading
up to his death, Willie had been distant and distracted,
trying to maintain the facade of a loving husband while
(02:30):
battling his inner turmoil. As Christmas approached in December twenty nineteen,
Willy's behavior began to change. He became more distant, spending
less time at home and more time working. Late. Lynne
noticed the change, but attributed it to the stress of
running the business during the busy holiday season. Friends and
neighbors also noticed that Willie seemed preoccupied, no longer as
(02:51):
cheerful as he once was. But no one could have
imagined the storm brewing beneath the surface, a storm that
would soon shatter the peace of their small town. It
was the morning of December twenty two, twenty nineteen, just
a few days before Christmas. Tifton, Georgia, was quiet, with
most of the town's residence finishing their holiday shopping or
decorating their homes. Around nine o'clock a m. Lynne Tanners,
(03:14):
Willy's wife, was returning home from her Sunday morning church
service at First Baptist Church, where she had volunteered to
help prepare for the upcoming Christmas Eve service. She noticed
Willie's truck parked in the driveway, which struck her as
odd since he had mentioned needing to pick up some
last minute supplies to his door. When Lynne entered their
home on Bride Street, the first thing she noticed was
(03:35):
the smell of fresh pine from the Christmas tree they
had decorated together. The tree was still lit with colorful lights,
and underneath it were neatly wrapped presents, some with her
name on them, but something was off. The house was
eerily silent, and Willie didn't respond when she called out
his name. As Lynne walked into the living room, she
was met with the sight that would haunt her forever.
(03:57):
Willie's lifeless body lay on the floor near the Christmas tree,
surrounded by shattered ornaments and tinsel. His head was soaked
in blood as if it were in Enchilada, and a
hammer lay nearby, covered in what she could only assume
was her husband's blood. Lynde dropped of her knees, her
body shaking as she tried to make sense of what
she was seeing. Panic set in, but Lynn forced herself
(04:18):
to stay calm enough to call nine one one. Her
voice trembled as she explained the situation to the operator,
kears streaming down her face. Oh my lordy, my husband's
not breathing. There's blood everywhere, she cried. The operator tried
to keep her calm, instructing her not to touch anything
and to wait outside for the police in paramedics. Within minutes,
(04:38):
the quiet street was filled with the flashing lights of
emergency vehicles. Neighbors peeked out from their windows, whispering to
each other and speculating about what had happened. Lynde sat
on the front porch nm man in shock, unable to
comprehend how her life had changed in an instant. The
Tifton Police Department arrived on the scene within minutes of
Lynde Tanner's nine to one one call. Leading the investigation
(05:01):
was Detective Nora Collins, a seasoned officer with over fifteen
years of experience, known for her sharp instincts and methodical approach.
Detective Collins was respected by her peers and feared by criminals.
As she stepped out of her unmarked cruiser, she was
immediately struck by the contrast between the festive decorations on
the Tanner's home and the grim scene awaiting her. Inside
(05:23):
the living room was a disturbing mix of holiday cheer
and brutal violence. Christmas lights twinkled on the tree, reflecting
off the shattered ornaments scattered across the floor. Willie Tanner's
body lay near the base of the tree, his head
caved in like a half eaten burrito from what appeared
to be multiple blows with a hammer. Blood had spattered
across the nearby gifts, soaking the wrapping paper and ribbons.
(05:46):
Detective Collins took in the scene, her mind racing as
she began to piece together what might have happened. The hammer,
still lying beside Willie's body, was immediately bagged as evidence.
The crime scene was bloody, but it was also oddly confined.
There were no signs of a struggle beyond the immediate
area around the tree. It was as if Willie had
been caught completely off guard. The forensic team arrived shortly after,
(06:09):
applied by doctor Philip k Wang, a meticulous and detail
oriented medical examiner who was known for his precise work.
Doctor Wang began examining Willie's body, noting the severe head
trauma that had likely caused instant death. He estimated the
time of death to be between ten o'clock PM and
midnight the previous evening based on the state of rigor mortis.
(06:31):
Detective Collins directed her team to collect every possible piece
of evidence. They dusted for fingerprints, took photographs, and searched
for any other clues that might point to the killer.
She also interviewed Lynne Tanners, who was still in shock,
but managed to provide a basic timeline of her mourning
and Willie's activities the previous day. As the investigation unfolded,
(06:53):
Detective Collins couldn't shake the feeling that this was a
crime of passion. The brutality of the attack suggested deep
anger were jealousy emotions that often fueled such violent outbursts.
But who could have hated Willy Tanners enough to kill
him in such a brutal way. That was the question
Collins was determined to answer. The first person Detective Nora
Collins decided to investigate was Madison Kelly, the eighteen year
(07:17):
old high school senior who had also been the secret
lover of Willie Tanners. Madison was known around Tifton as
a bright student with a promising future. She was involved
in several extracurricular activities, including the school's drama club, where
she had recently wrought audiences as Tiny Tim in a
local production of a Christmas Carol. But beneath her polished exterior,
(07:37):
Madison was emotionally fragile, a trait that had become more
apparent in recent months. Madison lived with her mother, Tammy Kelly,
in a small but tidy house on the outskirts of town.
The Kellys were known for keeping to themselves, and Tammy
was known in the community for being controlling and obsessed
with her daughter's appearance, especially her husband. Madison's father had
(07:57):
left the family after coming out as gay. When Detective
Collins arrived at the Kelly residence on the afternoon of
December twenty two, she found Madison still dressed in her
jammies in her bedroom, visibly shaken by the nudes of
Willie's death. The room was a typical teenager's sanctuary, filled
with posters of pop stars like Taylor Swift, and Ariana Grande,
(08:18):
but there were also signs of Madison's obsession with Willie.
Detective Collins noticed a framed, shirtless photo of Willie on
Madison's night stand, and her journals were filled with graphic
entries about their sexual relationship. During the interview, Madison was
initially cooperative, but quickly became emotional. When questioned about her
relationship with Willie. She admitted to the affair, describing how
(08:39):
they had grown close over the past year. Madison revealed
that she had fallen deeply in love with Willie and
had even fantasized about a future together. However, as Christmas approached,
Willie had become distant and she feared he was planning
to end their relationship. When detective Collins pressed Madison on
her whereabouts the night of the murder, Madison hesitated before
(09:01):
claiming she had been home alone studying for her final exams.
Her alibi was weak, and her emotional state raised red
flags for Collins. Madison's tears and trembling hands indicated that
she was under immense stress, but whether it was from
guilt or grief was unclear. As the interview continued, Madison's
demeanor shifted from sorrowful to defensive. She insisted she had
(09:23):
nothing to do with Willy's death and began to speak erratically,
blaming a mysterious man she called Bob for influencing her actions.
Madison claimed that Bob had convinced her to pursue a
sexual relationship with Willie or else he would torture her,
but when pressed for more details, she became evasive and confused.
Detective Collins was unconvinced by Madison's story. The combination of
(09:46):
her emotional instability, obsession with Willie, and weak alibi made
her a prime suspect. However, Collins knew she needed more
concrete evidence before she could make an arrest. The investigation
into Madison care Elly was far from over, and Collins
was determined to uncover the truth behind Willie Tanner's tragic death.
(10:07):
The second person on Detective Nora collins list was Lynn Tanner's,
Willie's wife of twenty five years. Lynn was a well
known figure in Tifton, recognized for her deep involvement in
the community and church activities. She was a warm and
friendly woman, always greeting neighbors with a smile and often
hosting gatherings at their home. Despite the outward appearance of
a happy marriage, detective Collins knew that Lynn had long
(10:29):
harbored suspicions about Willy's fidelity. Lynn had spent the days
leading up to the murder preparing for Christmas. She had
been busy with church events, including the upcoming Christmas Eve
service at First Baptist Church. To the outside world, it
seemed like Lynn was focused on her faith and family,
but inside she was troubled by a growing sense of unease.
(10:50):
She had noticed Willy's increasing absences, which he often explained
away as work related or part of his commitment to
the church. However, Lynn couldn't shake the field that something
was wrong. When Detective Collins interviewed Lynne on December twenty two,
Lynne was still in shock from discovering her husband's body
that morning. Sitting at the kitchen table, Lynne recounted her
(11:11):
marriage to Willie, describing him as a loving husband, but
also admitting that they had grown distant and sexless in
recent years, especially after their son Rifle left for college.
She confessed that she had suspected Willie of having an
affair after he kept turning down her requests for sex,
but had no proof. Lynde's eyes welled up with tears
as she spoke about the strain it had put on
(11:32):
their relationship, particularly in the last few months. Detective Collins
asked Lynne about her whereabouts on the night of the murder.
Lynde stated that she had been at home preparing for
the next day's church service. She had gone to bed early,
assuming Willie would join her later, but when she woke
up in the middle of the night and realized he
wasn't there, she assumed he had fallen asleep in the
(11:53):
living room. It wasn't until the next morning that she
discovered the gruesome truth. Lynde's acounted the evening was straightforward,
but Detective Collins couldn't ignore the possibility that Lynne's suspicions
about Willy's affair could have driven her to commit the murder.
The brutal nature of the crime suggested a deeply personal motive,
and as the wife of the victim, Lynne had both
(12:14):
the opportunity and a potential reason to kill. However, Lynde's
grief appeared genuine, and her cooperation with the investigation was unwavering.
She answered all of Collins's questions without hesitation and even
provided access to Willie's personal belongings, including his phone and computer. Still,
Collins knew that emotions could be powerful motivators, and she
(12:35):
wasn't ready to rule Len out as a suspect just yet.
The investigation continued, with Collins keeping a close eye on
every detail of Lynde's story. The third person Detective Nora
Collins needed to investigate was Tammy Kelly, the mother of
Madison Kelly, and a woman with a strong, willed, controlling personality.
Tammy was known around Tifton as a perfectionist, always concerned
(12:57):
with appearances and maintaining a strict household, especially after her
husband left her. After coming out of the closet, she
was active in the community, often organizing events at the
local church, but her primary focus was on her daughter, Madison.
Tammy's relationship with Madison had always been strained. Madison, who
was young, beautiful, and full of sexual potential, had been
(13:19):
the subject of Tammy's obsessive fear and attention. Tammy's control
over Madison extended to every aspect of her life, from
the clothes she wore to her social interactions. It was
well known among their neighbors that Tammy had high expectations
for her daughter and was often harsh when those expectations
weren't met. Rumors had circulated that Tammy disciplined medicine severely,
(13:41):
with one particularly disturbing story claiming that Tammy whipped Madison
whenever she thought her daughter's appearance was too attractive to
men in the community. Detective Collins approached Tammy on December
twenty three, the day after Willie Tanner's body was found.
Tammy was at home, seemingly unfazed by the events of
the past day. She welcomed Ellans into her clean living room,
(14:01):
decorated with traditional Christmas decorations, including a perfectly trimmed tree
and a Nativity scene. Tammy was calm and composed as
she spoke, but there was an underlying tension in her demeanor.
Collins began the interview by asking Tammy about her relationship
with Willie. Tammy was quick to praise Willie, describing him
distantly as a good man and a pillar of the community. However,
(14:24):
as the conversation shifted to Madison, Tammy's tone became more guarded.
She admitted that she had been angered about Madison's recent behavior,
noting that her daughter had begun wearing makeup and a
bra in the weeks leading up to the murder. When
Collins pressed Tammy about whether she knew of Madison's sexual
relationship with Willie, which was exactly what she was trying
to prevent, Tammy's composure faltered slightly. She denied any knowledge
(14:48):
of the affair, but admitted that she had noticed Madison
had begun to dress like a harlot. In Tammy's words,
Tammy claimed that she had tried to talk to Madison
about it, but her daughter had brushed her off. Everything
was fine. Collins couldn't ignore the possibility that Tammy's jealousy
and need for control could have driven her to commit
the murder. Tammy's intense need for control of her daughter,
(15:11):
combined with the potential scandal of Madison's sexual affair with
a much older man her worst nightmare, gave her a
possible motive. However, Tammy remained cool and collected throughout the interview,
showing no signs of yuilt or remorse. She was polite
and cooperative, but offered little useful information. As Collins left
the Kelly home, she knew Tammy couldn't be dismissed as
(15:33):
a suspect. The investigation was growing more complex, with each
suspect revealing new layers of potential motives and secrets, but
without hard evidence, Collins was still piecing together the puzzle.
On December twenty four, twenty nineteen, just one day before Christmas,
the investigation took a significant turn. It was a cold,
gray morning in Tifton, Georgia, with temperatures hovering around the
(15:56):
low forties. Detective Nora Collins and her team were back
of the Tanner's residence, meticulously calming through every inch of
the crime scene, determined to find any clue they might
have missed. As the team searched the house, one officer
noticed something odd near the fireplace. Amidst the neatly wrapped
Christmas presents, He found a small, torn piece of paper
partially tucked under the rug. The paper appeared to be
(16:19):
a handwritten note, but only a fragment was legible. It
read dirty boy meet me at followed by a time
ten o'clock PM, and the initials M KEY. This discovery
immediately caught Detective Collin's attention. The initials m K seemed
to match those of Madison Kelly Willie's secret lover. The
time mentioned in the note also coincided with the estimated
(16:41):
time of Willy's death. Collins realized that this could be
the key piece of evidence that linked Madison directly to
the crime scene on the night of the murder. Collins
quickly ordered a forensic analysis of the note, hoping to
determine if the handwriting matched Madison's. The note was sent
to the Georgia Bureau of Investigation in Atlanta for further examination. Meanwhile,
Collins decided to revisit Madison's home to search for anything
(17:04):
that might tie her to the note or the crime.
While at the Kelly residence, Collins and her teen found
a notebook in Madison's bedroom, hidden under her mattress. The
notebook was filled with disturbing entries about her obsession with Willie,
including plans to meet him in secret. One of the entries,
dated December twenty two, matched the time and place mentioned
in the torn note found at the Tanner's house. This
(17:26):
new evidence was crucial. It not only placed Madison at
the scene of the crime, but also provided a motive
driven by jealousy and obsession. Collins felt that the case
was beginning to come together, with the puzzle pieces finally
falling into place. Back at the station, the forensic analysis
confirmed that the handwriting on the note matched Madison's. This
was the break Collins had been waiting for. With this
(17:48):
new evidence, the focus of the investigation narrowed sharply on
Madison Kelly, making her the prime suspect in Willie Tanner's murder.
As the investigation progressed, all signs began pointing toward Madison Kelly,
Willie's eighteen year old secret lover. The small town of Tifton,
Georgia was already reeling from the news of Willie's brutal murder,
(18:09):
but what emerged from the investigation shocked everyone even more.
Madison's obsessive love for Willie had been building for months.
As the holiday season approached, her fear of being abandoned
grew stronger. She was terrified that Willie, a man more
than twice her age, would leave her behind to focus
on his family during Christmas. The thought of losing him
consumed her, driving her into a jealous rage. On the
(18:32):
night of December twenty one, twenty nineteen, Madison decided to
confront Willie at his home. Desperate for reassurance that he
still loved her, she did something drastic. She took off
all her clothes and begged him to have sex with her,
right then and there in the middle of the living room. Willie,
already feeling the pressure of his double life and fearing
that his wife would find out panicked, he tried to
(18:55):
end the relationship, fearing exposure and the consequences it would
bring to both their lives, but this only pushed Madison
over the edge. In a moment of uncontrollable fury, Madison snapped.
In a moment of uncontrollable fury, she grabbed a hammer
that Willie had planned to use for hanging Christmas lights
and beaconed to death with it. The scene was gruesome,
(19:15):
with the festive decorations in the living room contrasting sharply
with the violence of the crime. After the murder, Madison
knew she was in deep trouble. In a desperate attempt
to avoid punishment, she concocted a bizarre story. She feigned
having early onsets schizophrenia, claiming that a secret lover named
Bob had been manipulating her for years. According to her
(19:36):
elaborate tale, Bob was a high ranking politician involved in
wild sex rituals and secret satanic and Wickan practices. Madison
insisted that Bob had forced her into a life of
sin and ultimately commanded her to kill Willie. The police, however,
were unimpressed by her story. Detective Nora Collins, who had
been leading the investigation, saw through the lies. Despite Madison's
(19:59):
attempts to shift the blaying, the evidence was clear. The
handwriting on the note found at the crime scene matched
Madisons and her obsessive entries in her notebook painted a
picture of a young woman consumed by jealousy and rage.
When confronted with the evidence, Madison tried to change her story.
She claimed that Bob was merely a voice in her head,
that she was mentally ill, and that she hadn't been
(20:21):
in control of her actions. But the police didn't buy it.
They believed she was lying to cover up her crime.
On December twenty sixth, twenty nineteen, Madison Kelly was officially
arrested for the murder of Willie Tanners. She was taken
into custody without incident for demeanor eerily calm as she
was led away in handcuffs. The town of Tifton was
left in shock, struggling to comprehend how a young woman
(20:44):
with such a bright future could commit such a heinous act.
Willie's family, devastated by the loss, found some solace in
the fact that the person responsible for his death was
finally behind bars, but the pain of his absence, especially
during the holiday season, was something they would carry with
them for the rest of their lives. The trial of
Madison Kelly began in early February twenty twenty. The small
(21:06):
town of Tifton, Georgia, was gripped by the case, with
many locals following every detail closely. The courtroom was packed
as the prosecution and defense presented their cases. The prosecution,
led by District Attorney Robert Whitman, a seasoned attorney known
for his no nonsense approach, argued that Madison's crime was premeditated.
Whitman fifty two described how Madison's obsession with Willie Tanners
(21:29):
had reached a dangerous level, leading her to commit a
brutal murder when he tried to end their affair. He
emphasized the cold, calculated nature of the crime, pointing to
the evidence that Madison had brought the hammer with her,
fully intending to use it. Whitman also dismissed Madison's claims
of mental illness, calling it a desperate attempt to escape justice.
(21:50):
On the other side, the defense attorney, Karen Blackwell forty five,
who was known for her compassionate yet sharp legal mind,
argued that Madison was mentally unstable at the time of
the murder. Blackwell claimed that Madison had suffered from a
psychotic break driven by the fear of losing Willie and
the intense pressure of their secret relationship. She asked the
jury to consider Madison's troubled home life and the influence
(22:13):
it had on her mental state. Blackwell painted a picture
of a vulnerable young woman who had been manipulated by
an older man and who had finally snapped under the pressure.
Throughout the trial, Willy's family sat in the front row,
their faces etched with grief. They listened quietly as the
details of Willie's double life were laid bare for the
world to see. The pain of his betrayal was clear,
(22:34):
but so was their deep sorrow at his loss. After
several days of deliberation, the jury returned with a verdict
on February eighteen, twenty twenty. Madison Kelly was found guilty
of second degree murder. The judge sentenced her to twenty
five years in prison, with the possibility of parole after
fifteen years. The sentence brought mixed reactions. Some felt it
(22:56):
was too lenient given the brutality of the crime, while
others believed it was a fair acknowledgment of Madison's youth
and troubled mental state. Willie's family expressed relief that the
trial was over, but knew that the scars of this
tragedy would remain with them forever. After the trial concluded,
life in Tifton, Georgia slowly began to return to normal,
though the memory of the crime lingered. Willie Tanner's hardware store,
(23:19):
once a bustling hub in the community, closed its doors
for good. Without Willy to run it, his family decided
they couldn't keep the business going. The closure marked the
end of an era for the small town, leaving a
hole in the community that was difficult to fill. Madison
Kelly was transferred to a state prison, where she began
serving her twenty five year sentence. Despite her attempts to
(23:41):
feign mental illness during the trial, the prison psychiatric evaluations
found no evidence of schizophrenia or any other condition that
would have explained her actions. Madison spent her days in
relative isolation with few visitors. Her once promising future was
now a distant memory, replaced by the reality of a
life behind bars. Lynne Tanners, Willie's widow, struggled to cope
(24:03):
with the revelations about her husband's double life. The knowledge
that Willie had been unfaithful with an eighteen year old
girl was a heavy burden to bear. Despite the support
of her church community, Lynn withdrew from public life, choosing
to grieve in private. She eventually sold the family home
and moved to a nearby town, hoping for a fresh
start away from the memories that haunted her. Tammy Kelly,
(24:26):
Madison's mother, faced her own challenges after the trial. The
scandal had brought shame upon her family, and Tammy's once
ironclad grip on her daughter's life had chattered. Tammy became
a pariat in the community, with many blaming her controlling
nature for Madison's downfall. She too retreated from public view,
avoiding the judgmental stairs of her neighbors. For the residence
(24:46):
of Tifton, the events of December twenty nineteen served as
a stark reminder that even in a close knit community,
secrets confessed her and lead to tragedy. The town's Christmas
celebrations that year were muted as the the memory of
Willie Tanner's murder cast a long shadow over the holiday season.
It would take years for the community to heal, and
even then, the story of Madison Kelly and Willie Tanners
(25:09):
would be remembered as one of the darkest chapters in
Tifton's history.
Welcome to another episode of true crime Case Files. In
today's episode, we delve into a tragic tale of love, obsession,
and murder in the small town of Tifton, Georgia. The
story that follows is one of dark secrets, emotional turmoil,
and a brutal killing that left a lasting scar on
everyone involved. This is the case of a respected man
(00:20):
whose life ended in a nightmarish fashion by an unexpected killer,
leaving behind questions that would haunt the town forever. Willie
Tanners forty nine was a well known and respected figure
in the small southern town at Tifton, Georgia. He owned
Tanner's Hardware, a local store that had been serving the
community for over two decades. Known for its friendly service
(00:41):
and wide selection of tools and supplies, Tanner's Hardware was
the kind of place where neighbors could count on finding
what they needed, whether it was a simple screwdriver or
advice on how to fix a leaky faucet. Willie was
often seen behind the counter, greeting customers with a warm
smile and chatting about everything from the weather to last
night's episode of Jim. Willie's life appeared ideal to those
(01:02):
who knew him. He was married to Lynne Tanners, forty eight,
his high school sweetheart, and the couple was often involved
in local church activities and charity events. They lived in
a modest but well kept home, decorated for the holidays
with twinkling lights and a wraith on the front door.
Willie's pride and joy was his two thousand and seven
Ford F one hundred and fifty, which he named Billy
(01:25):
James Contester, which he kept in pristine condition. He was
also an avid fan of the University of Georgia Bulldogs,
and his saturdays in the fall were spent watching football games,
often with friends and family. However, beneath this seemingly perfect exterior,
Willie was hiding a dark secret. Despite his reputation as
a devoted husband and upstanding citizen, Willie had become involved
(01:48):
in a secret affair with Madison Kelly, an eighteen year
old high school senior. Madison, known for her striking looks
and intelligence, was a regular customer at the hardware store.
Over time, a friendship developed that quickly turned into a
sexual relationship. Torn between guilt and desire, Willie struggled with
his conscience. As the holiday season approached. He knew the
(02:10):
affair was wrong, but he was unable to break free
from the emotional entanglement that had developed. The relationship was
torrid and extremely intense, with Willie struggling between his guilt
and his growing attachment to Madison. In the days leading
up to his death, Willie had been distant and distracted,
trying to maintain the facade of a loving husband while
(02:30):
battling his inner turmoil. As Christmas approached in December twenty nineteen,
Willy's behavior began to change. He became more distant, spending
less time at home and more time working. Late. Lynne
noticed the change, but attributed it to the stress of
running the business during the busy holiday season. Friends and
neighbors also noticed that Willie seemed preoccupied, no longer as
(02:51):
cheerful as he once was. But no one could have
imagined the storm brewing beneath the surface, a storm that
would soon shatter the peace of their small town. It
was the morning of December twenty two, twenty nineteen, just
a few days before Christmas. Tifton, Georgia, was quiet, with
most of the town's residence finishing their holiday shopping or
decorating their homes. Around nine o'clock a m. Lynne Tanners,
(03:14):
Willy's wife, was returning home from her Sunday morning church
service at First Baptist Church, where she had volunteered to
help prepare for the upcoming Christmas Eve service. She noticed
Willie's truck parked in the driveway, which struck her as
odd since he had mentioned needing to pick up some
last minute supplies to his door. When Lynne entered their
home on Bride Street, the first thing she noticed was
(03:35):
the smell of fresh pine from the Christmas tree they
had decorated together. The tree was still lit with colorful lights,
and underneath it were neatly wrapped presents, some with her
name on them, but something was off. The house was
eerily silent, and Willie didn't respond when she called out
his name. As Lynne walked into the living room, she
was met with the sight that would haunt her forever.
(03:57):
Willie's lifeless body lay on the floor near the Christmas tree,
surrounded by shattered ornaments and tinsel. His head was soaked
in blood as if it were in Enchilada, and a
hammer lay nearby, covered in what she could only assume
was her husband's blood. Lynde dropped of her knees, her
body shaking as she tried to make sense of what
she was seeing. Panic set in, but Lynn forced herself
(04:18):
to stay calm enough to call nine one one. Her
voice trembled as she explained the situation to the operator,
kears streaming down her face. Oh my lordy, my husband's
not breathing. There's blood everywhere, she cried. The operator tried
to keep her calm, instructing her not to touch anything
and to wait outside for the police in paramedics. Within minutes,
(04:38):
the quiet street was filled with the flashing lights of
emergency vehicles. Neighbors peeked out from their windows, whispering to
each other and speculating about what had happened. Lynde sat
on the front porch nm man in shock, unable to
comprehend how her life had changed in an instant. The
Tifton Police Department arrived on the scene within minutes of
Lynde Tanner's nine to one one call. Leading the investigation
(05:01):
was Detective Nora Collins, a seasoned officer with over fifteen
years of experience, known for her sharp instincts and methodical approach.
Detective Collins was respected by her peers and feared by criminals.
As she stepped out of her unmarked cruiser, she was
immediately struck by the contrast between the festive decorations on
the Tanner's home and the grim scene awaiting her. Inside
(05:23):
the living room was a disturbing mix of holiday cheer
and brutal violence. Christmas lights twinkled on the tree, reflecting
off the shattered ornaments scattered across the floor. Willie Tanner's
body lay near the base of the tree, his head
caved in like a half eaten burrito from what appeared
to be multiple blows with a hammer. Blood had spattered
across the nearby gifts, soaking the wrapping paper and ribbons.
(05:46):
Detective Collins took in the scene, her mind racing as
she began to piece together what might have happened. The hammer,
still lying beside Willie's body, was immediately bagged as evidence.
The crime scene was bloody, but it was also oddly confined.
There were no signs of a struggle beyond the immediate
area around the tree. It was as if Willie had
been caught completely off guard. The forensic team arrived shortly after,
(06:09):
applied by doctor Philip k Wang, a meticulous and detail
oriented medical examiner who was known for his precise work.
Doctor Wang began examining Willie's body, noting the severe head
trauma that had likely caused instant death. He estimated the
time of death to be between ten o'clock PM and
midnight the previous evening based on the state of rigor mortis.
(06:31):
Detective Collins directed her team to collect every possible piece
of evidence. They dusted for fingerprints, took photographs, and searched
for any other clues that might point to the killer.
She also interviewed Lynne Tanners, who was still in shock,
but managed to provide a basic timeline of her mourning
and Willie's activities the previous day. As the investigation unfolded,
(06:53):
Detective Collins couldn't shake the feeling that this was a
crime of passion. The brutality of the attack suggested deep
anger were jealousy emotions that often fueled such violent outbursts.
But who could have hated Willy Tanners enough to kill
him in such a brutal way. That was the question
Collins was determined to answer. The first person Detective Nora
Collins decided to investigate was Madison Kelly, the eighteen year
(07:17):
old high school senior who had also been the secret
lover of Willie Tanners. Madison was known around Tifton as
a bright student with a promising future. She was involved
in several extracurricular activities, including the school's drama club, where
she had recently wrought audiences as Tiny Tim in a
local production of a Christmas Carol. But beneath her polished exterior,
(07:37):
Madison was emotionally fragile, a trait that had become more
apparent in recent months. Madison lived with her mother, Tammy Kelly,
in a small but tidy house on the outskirts of town.
The Kellys were known for keeping to themselves, and Tammy
was known in the community for being controlling and obsessed
with her daughter's appearance, especially her husband. Madison's father had
(07:57):
left the family after coming out as gay. When Detective
Collins arrived at the Kelly residence on the afternoon of
December twenty two, she found Madison still dressed in her
jammies in her bedroom, visibly shaken by the nudes of
Willie's death. The room was a typical teenager's sanctuary, filled
with posters of pop stars like Taylor Swift, and Ariana Grande,
(08:18):
but there were also signs of Madison's obsession with Willie.
Detective Collins noticed a framed, shirtless photo of Willie on
Madison's night stand, and her journals were filled with graphic
entries about their sexual relationship. During the interview, Madison was
initially cooperative, but quickly became emotional. When questioned about her
relationship with Willie. She admitted to the affair, describing how
(08:39):
they had grown close over the past year. Madison revealed
that she had fallen deeply in love with Willie and
had even fantasized about a future together. However, as Christmas approached,
Willie had become distant and she feared he was planning
to end their relationship. When detective Collins pressed Madison on
her whereabouts the night of the murder, Madison hesitated before
(09:01):
claiming she had been home alone studying for her final exams.
Her alibi was weak, and her emotional state raised red
flags for Collins. Madison's tears and trembling hands indicated that
she was under immense stress, but whether it was from
guilt or grief was unclear. As the interview continued, Madison's
demeanor shifted from sorrowful to defensive. She insisted she had
(09:23):
nothing to do with Willy's death and began to speak erratically,
blaming a mysterious man she called Bob for influencing her actions.
Madison claimed that Bob had convinced her to pursue a
sexual relationship with Willie or else he would torture her,
but when pressed for more details, she became evasive and confused.
Detective Collins was unconvinced by Madison's story. The combination of
(09:46):
her emotional instability, obsession with Willie, and weak alibi made
her a prime suspect. However, Collins knew she needed more
concrete evidence before she could make an arrest. The investigation
into Madison care Elly was far from over, and Collins
was determined to uncover the truth behind Willie Tanner's tragic death.
(10:07):
The second person on Detective Nora collins list was Lynn Tanner's,
Willie's wife of twenty five years. Lynn was a well
known figure in Tifton, recognized for her deep involvement in
the community and church activities. She was a warm and
friendly woman, always greeting neighbors with a smile and often
hosting gatherings at their home. Despite the outward appearance of
a happy marriage, detective Collins knew that Lynn had long
(10:29):
harbored suspicions about Willy's fidelity. Lynn had spent the days
leading up to the murder preparing for Christmas. She had
been busy with church events, including the upcoming Christmas Eve
service at First Baptist Church. To the outside world, it
seemed like Lynn was focused on her faith and family,
but inside she was troubled by a growing sense of unease.
(10:50):
She had noticed Willy's increasing absences, which he often explained
away as work related or part of his commitment to
the church. However, Lynn couldn't shake the field that something
was wrong. When Detective Collins interviewed Lynne on December twenty two,
Lynne was still in shock from discovering her husband's body
that morning. Sitting at the kitchen table, Lynne recounted her
(11:11):
marriage to Willie, describing him as a loving husband, but
also admitting that they had grown distant and sexless in
recent years, especially after their son Rifle left for college.
She confessed that she had suspected Willie of having an
affair after he kept turning down her requests for sex,
but had no proof. Lynde's eyes welled up with tears
as she spoke about the strain it had put on
(11:32):
their relationship, particularly in the last few months. Detective Collins
asked Lynne about her whereabouts on the night of the murder.
Lynde stated that she had been at home preparing for
the next day's church service. She had gone to bed early,
assuming Willie would join her later, but when she woke
up in the middle of the night and realized he
wasn't there, she assumed he had fallen asleep in the
(11:53):
living room. It wasn't until the next morning that she
discovered the gruesome truth. Lynde's acounted the evening was straightforward,
but Detective Collins couldn't ignore the possibility that Lynne's suspicions
about Willy's affair could have driven her to commit the murder.
The brutal nature of the crime suggested a deeply personal motive,
and as the wife of the victim, Lynne had both
(12:14):
the opportunity and a potential reason to kill. However, Lynde's
grief appeared genuine, and her cooperation with the investigation was unwavering.
She answered all of Collins's questions without hesitation and even
provided access to Willie's personal belongings, including his phone and computer. Still,
Collins knew that emotions could be powerful motivators, and she
(12:35):
wasn't ready to rule Len out as a suspect just yet.
The investigation continued, with Collins keeping a close eye on
every detail of Lynde's story. The third person Detective Nora
Collins needed to investigate was Tammy Kelly, the mother of
Madison Kelly, and a woman with a strong, willed, controlling personality.
Tammy was known around Tifton as a perfectionist, always concerned
(12:57):
with appearances and maintaining a strict household, especially after her
husband left her. After coming out of the closet, she
was active in the community, often organizing events at the
local church, but her primary focus was on her daughter, Madison.
Tammy's relationship with Madison had always been strained. Madison, who
was young, beautiful, and full of sexual potential, had been
(13:19):
the subject of Tammy's obsessive fear and attention. Tammy's control
over Madison extended to every aspect of her life, from
the clothes she wore to her social interactions. It was
well known among their neighbors that Tammy had high expectations
for her daughter and was often harsh when those expectations
weren't met. Rumors had circulated that Tammy disciplined medicine severely,
(13:41):
with one particularly disturbing story claiming that Tammy whipped Madison
whenever she thought her daughter's appearance was too attractive to
men in the community. Detective Collins approached Tammy on December
twenty three, the day after Willie Tanner's body was found.
Tammy was at home, seemingly unfazed by the events of
the past day. She welcomed Ellans into her clean living room,
(14:01):
decorated with traditional Christmas decorations, including a perfectly trimmed tree
and a Nativity scene. Tammy was calm and composed as
she spoke, but there was an underlying tension in her demeanor.
Collins began the interview by asking Tammy about her relationship
with Willie. Tammy was quick to praise Willie, describing him
distantly as a good man and a pillar of the community. However,
(14:24):
as the conversation shifted to Madison, Tammy's tone became more guarded.
She admitted that she had been angered about Madison's recent behavior,
noting that her daughter had begun wearing makeup and a
bra in the weeks leading up to the murder. When
Collins pressed Tammy about whether she knew of Madison's sexual
relationship with Willie, which was exactly what she was trying
to prevent, Tammy's composure faltered slightly. She denied any knowledge
(14:48):
of the affair, but admitted that she had noticed Madison
had begun to dress like a harlot. In Tammy's words,
Tammy claimed that she had tried to talk to Madison
about it, but her daughter had brushed her off. Everything
was fine. Collins couldn't ignore the possibility that Tammy's jealousy
and need for control could have driven her to commit
the murder. Tammy's intense need for control of her daughter,
(15:11):
combined with the potential scandal of Madison's sexual affair with
a much older man her worst nightmare, gave her a
possible motive. However, Tammy remained cool and collected throughout the interview,
showing no signs of yuilt or remorse. She was polite
and cooperative, but offered little useful information. As Collins left
the Kelly home, she knew Tammy couldn't be dismissed as
(15:33):
a suspect. The investigation was growing more complex, with each
suspect revealing new layers of potential motives and secrets, but
without hard evidence, Collins was still piecing together the puzzle.
On December twenty four, twenty nineteen, just one day before Christmas,
the investigation took a significant turn. It was a cold,
gray morning in Tifton, Georgia, with temperatures hovering around the
(15:56):
low forties. Detective Nora Collins and her team were back
of the Tanner's residence, meticulously calming through every inch of
the crime scene, determined to find any clue they might
have missed. As the team searched the house, one officer
noticed something odd near the fireplace. Amidst the neatly wrapped
Christmas presents, He found a small, torn piece of paper
partially tucked under the rug. The paper appeared to be
(16:19):
a handwritten note, but only a fragment was legible. It
read dirty boy meet me at followed by a time
ten o'clock PM, and the initials M KEY. This discovery
immediately caught Detective Collin's attention. The initials m K seemed
to match those of Madison Kelly Willie's secret lover. The
time mentioned in the note also coincided with the estimated
(16:41):
time of Willy's death. Collins realized that this could be
the key piece of evidence that linked Madison directly to
the crime scene on the night of the murder. Collins
quickly ordered a forensic analysis of the note, hoping to
determine if the handwriting matched Madison's. The note was sent
to the Georgia Bureau of Investigation in Atlanta for further examination. Meanwhile,
Collins decided to revisit Madison's home to search for anything
(17:04):
that might tie her to the note or the crime.
While at the Kelly residence, Collins and her teen found
a notebook in Madison's bedroom, hidden under her mattress. The
notebook was filled with disturbing entries about her obsession with Willie,
including plans to meet him in secret. One of the entries,
dated December twenty two, matched the time and place mentioned
in the torn note found at the Tanner's house. This
(17:26):
new evidence was crucial. It not only placed Madison at
the scene of the crime, but also provided a motive
driven by jealousy and obsession. Collins felt that the case
was beginning to come together, with the puzzle pieces finally
falling into place. Back at the station, the forensic analysis
confirmed that the handwriting on the note matched Madison's. This
was the break Collins had been waiting for. With this
(17:48):
new evidence, the focus of the investigation narrowed sharply on
Madison Kelly, making her the prime suspect in Willie Tanner's murder.
As the investigation progressed, all signs began pointing toward Madison Kelly,
Willie's eighteen year old secret lover. The small town of Tifton,
Georgia was already reeling from the news of Willie's brutal murder,
(18:09):
but what emerged from the investigation shocked everyone even more.
Madison's obsessive love for Willie had been building for months.
As the holiday season approached, her fear of being abandoned
grew stronger. She was terrified that Willie, a man more
than twice her age, would leave her behind to focus
on his family during Christmas. The thought of losing him
consumed her, driving her into a jealous rage. On the
(18:32):
night of December twenty one, twenty nineteen, Madison decided to
confront Willie at his home. Desperate for reassurance that he
still loved her, she did something drastic. She took off
all her clothes and begged him to have sex with her,
right then and there in the middle of the living room. Willie,
already feeling the pressure of his double life and fearing
that his wife would find out panicked, he tried to
(18:55):
end the relationship, fearing exposure and the consequences it would
bring to both their lives, but this only pushed Madison
over the edge. In a moment of uncontrollable fury, Madison snapped.
In a moment of uncontrollable fury, she grabbed a hammer
that Willie had planned to use for hanging Christmas lights
and beaconed to death with it. The scene was gruesome,
(19:15):
with the festive decorations in the living room contrasting sharply
with the violence of the crime. After the murder, Madison
knew she was in deep trouble. In a desperate attempt
to avoid punishment, she concocted a bizarre story. She feigned
having early onsets schizophrenia, claiming that a secret lover named
Bob had been manipulating her for years. According to her
(19:36):
elaborate tale, Bob was a high ranking politician involved in
wild sex rituals and secret satanic and Wickan practices. Madison
insisted that Bob had forced her into a life of
sin and ultimately commanded her to kill Willie. The police, however,
were unimpressed by her story. Detective Nora Collins, who had
been leading the investigation, saw through the lies. Despite Madison's
(19:59):
attempts to shift the blaying, the evidence was clear. The
handwriting on the note found at the crime scene matched
Madisons and her obsessive entries in her notebook painted a
picture of a young woman consumed by jealousy and rage.
When confronted with the evidence, Madison tried to change her story.
She claimed that Bob was merely a voice in her head,
that she was mentally ill, and that she hadn't been
(20:21):
in control of her actions. But the police didn't buy it.
They believed she was lying to cover up her crime.
On December twenty sixth, twenty nineteen, Madison Kelly was officially
arrested for the murder of Willie Tanners. She was taken
into custody without incident for demeanor eerily calm as she
was led away in handcuffs. The town of Tifton was
left in shock, struggling to comprehend how a young woman
(20:44):
with such a bright future could commit such a heinous act.
Willie's family, devastated by the loss, found some solace in
the fact that the person responsible for his death was
finally behind bars, but the pain of his absence, especially
during the holiday season, was something they would carry with
them for the rest of their lives. The trial of
Madison Kelly began in early February twenty twenty. The small
(21:06):
town of Tifton, Georgia, was gripped by the case, with
many locals following every detail closely. The courtroom was packed
as the prosecution and defense presented their cases. The prosecution,
led by District Attorney Robert Whitman, a seasoned attorney known
for his no nonsense approach, argued that Madison's crime was premeditated.
Whitman fifty two described how Madison's obsession with Willie Tanners
(21:29):
had reached a dangerous level, leading her to commit a
brutal murder when he tried to end their affair. He
emphasized the cold, calculated nature of the crime, pointing to
the evidence that Madison had brought the hammer with her,
fully intending to use it. Whitman also dismissed Madison's claims
of mental illness, calling it a desperate attempt to escape justice.
(21:50):
On the other side, the defense attorney, Karen Blackwell forty five,
who was known for her compassionate yet sharp legal mind,
argued that Madison was mentally unstable at the time of
the murder. Blackwell claimed that Madison had suffered from a
psychotic break driven by the fear of losing Willie and
the intense pressure of their secret relationship. She asked the
jury to consider Madison's troubled home life and the influence
(22:13):
it had on her mental state. Blackwell painted a picture
of a vulnerable young woman who had been manipulated by
an older man and who had finally snapped under the pressure.
Throughout the trial, Willy's family sat in the front row,
their faces etched with grief. They listened quietly as the
details of Willie's double life were laid bare for the
world to see. The pain of his betrayal was clear,
(22:34):
but so was their deep sorrow at his loss. After
several days of deliberation, the jury returned with a verdict
on February eighteen, twenty twenty. Madison Kelly was found guilty
of second degree murder. The judge sentenced her to twenty
five years in prison, with the possibility of parole after
fifteen years. The sentence brought mixed reactions. Some felt it
(22:56):
was too lenient given the brutality of the crime, while
others believed it was a fair acknowledgment of Madison's youth
and troubled mental state. Willie's family expressed relief that the
trial was over, but knew that the scars of this
tragedy would remain with them forever. After the trial concluded,
life in Tifton, Georgia slowly began to return to normal,
though the memory of the crime lingered. Willie Tanner's hardware store,
(23:19):
once a bustling hub in the community, closed its doors
for good. Without Willy to run it, his family decided
they couldn't keep the business going. The closure marked the
end of an era for the small town, leaving a
hole in the community that was difficult to fill. Madison
Kelly was transferred to a state prison, where she began
serving her twenty five year sentence. Despite her attempts to
(23:41):
feign mental illness during the trial, the prison psychiatric evaluations
found no evidence of schizophrenia or any other condition that
would have explained her actions. Madison spent her days in
relative isolation with few visitors. Her once promising future was
now a distant memory, replaced by the reality of a
life behind bars. Lynne Tanners, Willie's widow, struggled to cope
(24:03):
with the revelations about her husband's double life. The knowledge
that Willie had been unfaithful with an eighteen year old
girl was a heavy burden to bear. Despite the support
of her church community, Lynn withdrew from public life, choosing
to grieve in private. She eventually sold the family home
and moved to a nearby town, hoping for a fresh
start away from the memories that haunted her. Tammy Kelly,
(24:26):
Madison's mother, faced her own challenges after the trial. The
scandal had brought shame upon her family, and Tammy's once
ironclad grip on her daughter's life had chattered. Tammy became
a pariat in the community, with many blaming her controlling
nature for Madison's downfall. She too retreated from public view,
avoiding the judgmental stairs of her neighbors. For the residence
(24:46):
of Tifton, the events of December twenty nineteen served as
a stark reminder that even in a close knit community,
secrets confessed her and lead to tragedy. The town's Christmas
celebrations that year were muted as the the memory of
Willie Tanner's murder cast a long shadow over the holiday season.
It would take years for the community to heal, and
even then, the story of Madison Kelly and Willie Tanners
(25:09):
would be remembered as one of the darkest chapters in
Tifton's history.
Popular Podcasts
Las Culturistas with Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang
Ding dong! Join your culture consultants, Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang, on an unforgettable journey into the beating heart of CULTURE. Alongside sizzling special guests, they GET INTO the hottest pop-culture moments of the day and the formative cultural experiences that turned them into Culturistas. Produced by the Big Money Players Network and iHeartRadio.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
Model Wars
On the surface, the modeling industry in the 80s was about parties and pretty clothes, but underneath the flash, there were drugs, sex, and violence. And Paul Fisher, a former straight-A student from the San Fernando Valley, rose to prominence amidst the turmoil. After a chance encounter with an alleged mobster, Paul suddenly found himself with a million dollars in funding and the chance to start a modeling agency in New York City. The city was then embroiled in a “model war” between industry titans Eileen Ford and John Casablancas, and Paul tried to make his mark. But even as Paul thrived in the party-heavy culture of the time, burning cash like a furnace, he came face to face with the darkest forces in the industry. As his shady backers put the screws to him, Paul faced down deadly consequences, trying to make a star while saving his soul.