First Date Follow Up - The Jubal Show

Haley thought her first date with Nate went almost perfectly—a romantic picnic, wine, a little slow dancing, and even a kiss. So why did he suddenly disappear? She has one theory about what went wrong, but when the show calls Nate to get the real story, his answer takes the conversation in a completely different direction.

Will Haley find out why she was ghosted—and more importantly, will Nate agree to give her a second...

Teddy thought his first date with Maya went great. They had good conversation, talked about their goals, and seemed to have plenty in common. But after the date, Maya suddenly stopped responding—and Teddy had no idea why.

When The Jubal Show gets Maya on the phone for a First Date Follow-Up, she finally explains what happened. Her version of the date is very different from Teddy's, and one unexpected detail abo...

Madeline thought she knew exactly why Jesse was ghosting her after their first date. After all, she had accidentally punched him in the nuts while trying to go in for a handshake. But when Jesse finally explains why he really disappeared, there’s another unforgettable moment from the date that changes everything.

What happened at dinner involving a shoe, a smell test, and a plate of calamari? And why does Jesse...

Liz thought her first date with Elliot was basically perfect—it lasted nearly 24 hours, included multiple stops, plenty of laughs, and ended with a sleepover. Then suddenly… nothing. Now we call Elliot to find out why he disappeared, and his answer leads to an unexpected conversation about ghosting, texting, dating expectations, and whether these two might get another chance.

Ever been ghosted after what you thought wa...

Remy thought his first date with Tarika went incredibly well—they spent hours together, hit three different spots, and seemed to be vibing. But after two weeks of silence, he has no idea why she's suddenly ghosting him. When The Jubal Show finally gets Tarika on the phone, the reason is so unexpected that Remy may never look at frozen yogurt the same way again. Will this First Date Follow-Up lead to another date, or is one ve...

Fiona thought her date with Nolan went really well, but then… nothing. 👀 Now she’s wondering what happened and why he suddenly disappeared. The Jubal Show steps in to get some answers, and the conversation takes an unexpected turn. Will Fiona get the answers she’s looking for—and maybe a second date?

Support the show: https://the-jubal-show.beehiiv.com/subscribe

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy inform...

Wesley thinks he knows exactly why Layla ghosted him after their first date—but the real reason is something he never expected her to notice. When The Jubal Show calls Layla for a First Date Follow Up, Wesley gets a chance to defend himself, explain what happened, and possibly earn a second date. But there's one awkward question he definitely wasn't prepared for…

Ever been ghosted after what you thought was an amazing ...

Alyssa thought her date with Bryce was almost too good to be true. They connected online over their love of French Bulldogs, hit it off during an Italian cooking class, and even ended the night with some serious chemistry. Then… nothing. After two weeks of silence, we call Bryce to find out why he disappeared—and his answer is definitely not what Alyssa expected. Will they get a second date? Listen to this First Date F...

Craig thought his date with Bailey was a total success—great conversation, a romantic ending, and plenty of chemistry. So why did she suddenly stop responding? When The Jubal Show gets Bailey on the phone for a First Date Follow Up, her reason for ghosting Craig sparks a brutally honest conversation about dating, attraction, first impressions, and whether one small detail can ruin an entire date.

Listen to find out what reall...

Liam thought his first date with Grace went great—and even ended with a kiss. But when she suddenly stopped responding, he had no idea what went wrong. He suspects one awkward joke may have ruined everything… but when Grace finally reveals the real reason she's ghosting him, it’s WAY more ridiculous than he expected.

Listen to this hilarious First Date Follow Up to hear the full story, including the jokes that ha...

Angel thought she knew exactly why Cooper was ghosting her after an amazing first date—but the real reason turns out to be far more unexpected. A mistaken text, some serious Twilight opinions, and a heated Team Edward vs. Team Jacob debate send this First Date Follow Up in a direction nobody saw coming.

Will Angel and Cooper get a second date, or will their differences finally be too much? Listen to The Jubal Show’s Fir...

Nicole thought she had a fun first date with Trevor, complete with pickleball, smoothies, and plenty of flirting. But after nine days of silence, she finds out the reason he disappeared is something she never could have predicted. When the two finally confront each other on the First Date Follow Up, things get hilariously competitive—and surprisingly personal. Tune in to hear why one tiny pickleball mistake turned this promis...

Ryan thought his date with Morgan went perfectly—great conversation, dinner, chemistry, and even a kiss. So why did she suddenly stop responding? During this hilarious First Date Follow Up, Morgan reveals the unexpected reason she decided Ryan wasn't worth a second date—and it turns into a heated debate about honesty, dating red flags, and an unusual relationship “test.” Listen to The Jubal Show First Date F...

Rose thinks she knows exactly why Henry ghosted her after their first date—and it has nothing to do with the mystery smell on her pants. When the First Date Follow Up crew finally gets Henry on the phone, he reveals something about Rose that immediately made him suspicious. 😳

But Rose has an explanation for the strange behavior, and it leads to an unexpected confession about her life outside of work. Will Henry finally under...

Megan thought her first date with Tyler was going great—until he suddenly disappeared. After a competitive night of trivia, a little confidence, and some playful moves, she has no idea why she’s being ghosted. On The Jubal Show’s First Date Follow Up, Tyler finally reveals the real reason he stopped calling, and it has everything to do with one moment from their night out that he says he can’t forget. Will t...

Selena thought she and Justin had the perfect first date—great food, easy conversation, and what felt like undeniable chemistry. But after one surprising moment during their picnic, Justin completely disappeared. Was it a misunderstanding, an innocent habit, or something he simply couldn't get past? Listen to this hilarious First Date Follow-Up to find out what real...

Alicia thought she had found the perfect match after an amazing first date—great conversation, a sweet kiss, and all the signs pointed toward date number two. Then... complete silence. When First Date Follow Up gets Jason on the phone, the reason he disappeared is so unexpected that everyone is left stunned. Was it an innocent mix-up, or was there more to the story?

What started as a fun first date filled with tequila flights, salsa dares, and nonstop laughs suddenly took a bizarre turn when one name kept coming up: Gilbert. The more the conversation unfolded, the more confused her date became—and it ultimately led to him disappearing. But when The Jubal Show's First Date Follow-Up gets b...

Shane thought the biggest reason he'd been ghosted was an embarrassing moment involving a trumpet at a night market—but the real reason catches everyone completely off guard. What starts as a funny First Date Follow-Up quickly turns into one of the most bizarre dating stories the show has ever heard, complete with a reveal that has the hosts—and the listener—questioning everything. Was this harmless, adorable, or ...