March 9, 2024 | Labor Market, JOLTs Report, China, Personal Consumption Expenditures and Social Security Changes Coming?

Labor Market

While the headline number of 275k jobs created easily topped the estimate of 198k and sparked concerns the labor market remained too hot, the details of the report showed a much softer labor market. To begin, the prior two months saw a downward revision of 167k jobs, which more than offsets the beat we saw in the month of February. Also, while I generally am a little more skeptical of the household survey, it did show a decline of 184k in those that were counted as employed, which led to an uptick in the unemployment rate to 3.9%. This was above the estimate of 3.7%. I was also disappointed to see that government remained a large contributor in the establishment survey as the sector added 52k jobs. Outside of government, other areas that were strong included health care & social assistance (+90.7k), leisure & hospitality (+58k), and construction (+23k). Wage gains were also a bright spot in the report as average hourly earnings increased 4.3% compared to last year. This was below the estimate of 4.4% and below last month’s reading of 4.5%. I believe this report continues to put us on track for 3-4 rate cuts in the back part of the year.

JOLTs Report

The January Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTs) was right in line with expectations and the previous month as job openings totaled about 8.9 million. This remains well below the high of 12.2 million in March 2022, but is still well above historical norms as prepandemic we had not seen a reading above 8 million. I continue to believe job openings will continue to trend lower to come back in line with historic levels. This does not mean we believe we are seeing a weak labor market, but I would call it a normalizing labor market. We have also seen a normalization in quits which should be a positive for wage pressure. Quits in the month were 3.4 million. This compares to annual quits of 44.4 million or 3.7 million per month in 2023. Total quits in 2023 fell by 6.1 million when compared to 2022. Looking at prepandemic levels, quits totaled 42.1 million in 2019 which would have been an average of 3.5 million. Layoffs were also strong in the month as they totaled just 1.6 million. This is right in line with 2023 levels as for the full year they totaled 19.8 million and averaged 1.65 million per month. In 2019, layoffs totaled 21.7 million and averaged 1.8 million per month. I wanted to provide all this data to show the labor market may be softening from strong levels, but I believe there is still some room to have numbers normalize without tilting us into a weak labor market.

China

What happened to China? The country had such a robust economy just a few short years ago, but the writing was on the wall. Here are the problems that caused the economic downfall. A real estate boom which accounted for 25% of China’s annual economic output. The debt and inventory continued to rise in houses and condos but many remained empty with no one able to buy them. The government cutoff the debt to developers, which ended the real estate boom. Consumers who did buy into the expensive housing market in China leveraged beyond their means with the expectation that the growth would continue and they could sell out with a profit. Unfortunately, they are now sitting under water in much of their real estate, but still have to pay the debt and don’t have much discretionary income to spend in other parts of the economy. China is now experiencing deflation, which will give them negative growth in parts of their economy for perhaps years to come. China’s overall debts have now surpassed 300% of GDP with very little chance of the economy growing to pay down that debt. Many years ago, they put a cap on how many babies people could have and now that is hurting them with an aging workforce and a shrinking workforce. It will take years to reverse this. In the meantime, the economy remains underwater. Since 1998 foreign investment in China has always been on the upswing, but that run came to an end in the third quarter of 2023 as foreign companies sold out and left or just stopped investing in China. There is nothing left to build in China when looking at their infrastructure. They have built many roads, railroads and airports so there’ll be no future investment in infrastructure. China has always been a communist country and I don’t think they really understood capitalism very well. An economy will always go through the ups and downs, but the United States has been around for 200 years and we have learned some valuable lessons like 1929 and 2008. While we can’t avoid the down turns, we have learned how to minimize the depths of the down turns.

Personal Consumption Expenditures

The Personal Consumption Expenditures Price Index, known as the PCE and is the main inflation gauge that the Federal Reserve looks at came in with a good inflation number. Excluding food and energy the change from one year ago for January was 2.8